shopify stats
Human Trafficking Center

Human trafficking: What about the men and boys?

18

Sep 2014

28

 

by Ashley Greve, Associate Director of Advocacy

If “male prostitute” is an uncommonly heard term, then “male sex trafficking victim” is rarer still. If you looked at the early literature, legislation and media coverage of sex trafficking, it would appear that the commercial sexual exploitation of men and boys is a relatively new concept, something that did not exist until recent years. In reality, men and boys are subjected to commercial sexual exploitation in many countries around the world, and they even outnumber female victims within certain subcategories of trafficking. To ignore these facts is not only inaccurate, but also dangerous – it has led to the oblivious abandonment of tens of thousands of victims.

The Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act (TVPA) of 2000—the legal impetus behind the counter-trafficking movement in the United States—is actually split into three divisions, one devoted entirely to the Violence Against Women Act. It is an apropos attachment to a document declaring that “At least 700,000 persons annually, primarily women and children, are trafficked within or across international borders. Approximately 50,000 women and children are trafficked into the United States each year.” It goes on to state, “Many of these persons are trafficked into the international sex trade, often by force, fraud, or coercion…It involves sexual exploitation of persons, predominantly women and girls, involving activities related to prostitution, pornography, sex tourism, and other commercial sexual services” (emphases all mine).

While it is indisputable that the vast majority of survivors of commercial sexual exploitation are female (likely around 98 percent, according to the International Labour Organization), it is not true that women and girls constitute the vast majority of all human trafficking victims globally. The same source approximates that 42 percent of victims of state-imposed labor exploitation are male. That number increases to 60 percent when considering labor exploitation in private economies. When you add sex trafficking data, this does mean that more of the nearly 21 million victims worldwide are female than male. Nevertheless, the difference is not so disparate as to merit neglecting the men and boys involved.

And what about that 2 percent of victims of commercial sexual exploitation that is male? Are these 400,000 men and boys being overlooked? As awareness of male victimization has increased, so has recognition of the plight of individual male victims. Early versions of the Department of State’s Trafficking in Persons Reports—which are undoubtedly some of the most comprehensive sources of country-specific human trafficking information—have very few references to male victims of sex trafficking. In 2007, Japan, Malta and Slovenia acknowledged the existence of the problem. In contrast, the latest report (2014) contains references to this phenomenon in the narratives for Bolivia, Brazil, Canada, Columbia, El Salvador, Eritrea, France, Ghana, Iceland, Israel, Kenya, the Philippines and Qatar. It is likely happening in many more countries, but expectations of who constitutes a trafficking victim, as well as culturally reinforced ideas of who can be victimized, prevent further reports of male sex trafficking from being made or taken seriously.

If a single victim is one victim too many, then human trafficking experts, first responders and service providers must first be aware of the very real exploitation of men and boys in human trafficking—both for labor and for commercial sexual purposes. They must learn to devote equal attention to all genders when screening potential victims and to provide appropriate and sufficient services for all those who are victimized, not merely those who fit a stereotypical description of a victim/survivor of human trafficking.

The mainstream media and well-intentioned but misinformed or inadequately trained professionals within the counter-trafficking movement have perpetuated the image of a young, foreign, female victim. Just as it is easier to believe that a foreigner is a victim of trafficking than a U.S.-born citizen because it helps to externalize the danger onto a separate population, it may also be easier to believe that only the “weaker sex” is victimized. This notion is wrong and it is harmful. While women and girls obviously deserve protection, correcting false perceptions is the first step toward ensuring that boys—and yes, men—are also safe.

28 Responses to “Human trafficking: What about the men and boys?”

  1. Human trafficking: a look at gender – Human Trafficking new lenses

    […] Greve, Ashley. (2014, Sept. 18). Human trafficking: What about the men and boys? [Web log]. Retrieved from http://humantraffickingcenter.org/men-boys/ […]

  2. Human Trafficking: A Look at Gender – Human Trafficking: The Lenses

    […] Greve, Ashley. (2014, Sept. 18). Human trafficking: What about the men and boys? [Web log]. Retrieved from http://humantraffickingcenter.org/men-boys/ […]

  3. Human Trafficking new lenses

    […] September 18). Human trafficking: What about the men and boys? Retrieved August 22, 2017, from http://humantraffickingcenter.org/men-boys/ National Human Trafficking Resource Center (NHTRC)(), NHTRC Student Toolkit. 1-12. Postman, N. […]

  4. Human Trafficking: The Lenses

    […] September 18). Human trafficking: What about the men and boys? Retrieved August 22, 2017, from http://humantraffickingcenter.org/men-boys/ National Human Trafficking Resource Center (NHTRC)(), NHTRC Student Toolkit. 1-12. Postman, N. […]

  5. Feminism – Is It Needed? – unlovedsinner

    […] Cites: Women Gained The Right To Vote In 1920 Colored People Gained The Right To Vote In 1870 List Of All U.S. Presidents Percent Of Men Vs Women Who Have A Business Degree Percentage Of Street Harassment Against Women Male Vs Female Rape Gender/Race Pay Gap Reasons For Gender Pay Gap In U.S.A Male Eating Disorders Impacted By Beauty Standards Public Opinion On Abortion What The Global Gag Rule Really Is 6-Year-Old Girls And Their Intelligence Female Members Of Congress Human Trafficking – Men Included […]

  6. Stereotyping Sex Trafficking – In The Pocket

    […] 1.Ashley Greve. (2016). Human trafficking: What about the men and boys? | Human Trafficking CenterHuman Trafficking Center. Retrieved April 24, 2017, from http://humantraffickingcenter.org/men-boys/ […]

  7. International Women’s Day: Why we march! |

    […] are several other types, like labor human trafficking which almost half are males.  UNODC    What about men and boys?  Who’s protecting the little girls (and […]

  8. Don’t Forget the Men: Supporting Male Victims of Sexual Exploitation | DECSA

    […] words “sexual exploitation?” How about “human trafficking?” “Prostitution?” Research suggests you’re probably picturing a woman, as this is the image associated most strongly and persistently […]

  9. David

    I am so glad the word is getting around about human trafficking. I to was a victim, but I was a victim to be internationally sex trafficked, that’s right, I was to be taken out of the U.S. to Bulgaria. All this took place in 1987 in the airport in St. Louis. I was only 17 at the time and I let myself be lured by a pretty girl,my mistake, I should have known something to good to be true was exactly that, but being 17 and with a pretty girl taking interest in me, well it could have happened to anyone. I got very lucky, I escaped her and her cohorts. What made me so mad was I immediately reported them, but I wasn’t belwived, I was told, things like this don’t happen here. Thank God now they are a lot of people taking interest, and they are hope now. They didn’t take me physically that night, but they took a part of me with them that bight, and for 29 1/2 years it’s bothered me. I am doing better now talking about it more and more than bottling it up. what I can never understand is why the FBI hasn’t figures out the so many teenagers that went missing during the 80’s and never found were more than likely internationally sex trafficked. This if for real, it happens and never think it can’t happen to you or in your part of the country, this affects more people than you know. Keep up the good work and get the message out to more and more that can do something about this non since.

    • Christine

      Have you heard of Enrique Rios he was from yolo county California and he went missing last year 10/16 he was 16 then just a couple weeks later his friend went missing I have a bad feeling that their families think they are just missing and not trafficked they could be over looking the possibility and don’t believe it can happen to boys but I have a strange feeling that they may have. how can they be located?

      • David

        I have heard all about what went on in California,but this is happening all over the U.S. right now, and it’s sad. The police seem to be dragging around as usual,and not opening up there minds to ALL possibilities of why they are missing, and not wait 24 hours or however long they wait for them to show up somewhere. Every time someone that goes missing, it brings me back to that dreaded night back in 1987 at Lambert Field in St.Louis. I will never ever forget that night nor the exact time it happened. I know that the victim will be scared forever, and what’s sad if any of them make it out, they just aren’t anyone to turn to immediately for the proper help. They just simply not enough places to go to receive any help for something like this. For me, I had to travel 300 miles away to the right people that know how and what to do with us trafficked victims. I will be willing to bet,they are a lot more victims out there, that are simply afraid to say anything to the local police about what’s happened, cause where are the police going to take you so you can get help from UNDERSTANDING people. People that are experienced in trafficked victims, and it’s sad, cause it seems more and more trafficked victims are coming from rural areas. They just aren’t anywhere to go for help, trust me, I know, I’ve been there, needing someone, and they are no one. You would think in a country, such as ours, well it wouldn’t be that hard to get help from UNDERSTANDING people , but it is, and to why is this not giving the recongnition it needs to stop this non since, and the authorities need to change the ways and look immediately into the person being trafficked, before it’s to late and the victim is never seen again. I’m still hoping our New president and his New administration will do something to stop this, before this gets worse.

    • Yvon

      God bless u n may He continue to keep His face shining brightly upon you. He has laid it on my heart to help young men like you. I pray you continue to be bold and share your story with all, to help bring awareness, prevention in turn bringing light and hope to others. If only one be saved or prevented from going off with one of these ppl …it will all be for His glory…much love dear one..praising God for you!

  10. Ashleigh

    I would like more information about this. If anyone has any links please send them to me.

    • Jasmine @JasNotes

      Hi Ashleigh,
      The story of Jerome Elam (@JeromeElam) is a HUGE eyeopener into sexual abuse and trafficking of American boy, “I was a 5yr old sex slave”
      -http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2905025/I-five-year-old-sex-slave-Florida-man-reveals-childhood-trafficked-FAMILY-thousands-clients-choked-raped-him.html
      -Check also the Trafficking in America Taskforce with great resources for men. http://traffickinginamericataskforce.org
      -Also this article, “Pathway to Recovery” –halfway in shares about the amazing lack of resources and restorative services for men–apparently only 2 providers in the entire USA: http://opportunitylives.com/a-path-to-recovery-for-child-domestic-trafficking-victims/
      -A recent wake of Pro footballers in UK sharing about abuse they suffered as boys in sports clubs has caused widespread investigations, raising awareness in other European countries.
      -And now also news is coming out about rape as warcrime against men in conflict areas.. https://www.ictj.org/publication/sexual-violence-men-boys

      • brad crompton

        I HAD SAW AAAAAAAN ARTICLE AND IT WAS ASSERTED BUT NO PRESECUTION OR HARD EVIDENCE THAT PRIESTS ARE CLIENTS. tHE HORROR OF MAKING 5 YEAR OD BOYS BECOMING PROFICIENT IN SEX ACTS AD ALL THEIR PERVERSIONS. tHESE BOYS LOOSE THEIR CHILHOOD AAND ARE LEFT WITH MEMORIES THAT WILL NEEEEVER GO AWAY , tHERE IS A CORRELATION BETWEEN SEX ABUSE AND DRUG DEPENDENCE AND WHO THE HELL CAN BLAME THEM

  11. Mary Muyama

    Nice piece of work on the world of war against illegal trafficking.

    Look forward to watch the film.

  12. Film Review: Sold – rex.hamaker

    […] trafficking, coverage of female sex trafficking often comes at the expense of labor as well as men and boys. This also assumes there is a clear divide between labor and sexual exploitation andmakes […]

    • brad crompton

      It is just a true nightmare. With so many men today having sex with other I understand why those bastards would ruin young boys life forever. I imagine the mental anguish of old men seually abusing then doin horrid and unseemly

  13. Is the Media Helping or Harming Anti-Trafficking Efforts? | Human Trafficking Center

    […] for forced labor is actually more prevalent than sex trafficking. And even within sex trafficking, men and boys are exploited, albeit in smaller numbers. While sex trafficking is an important problem to combat, it shouldn’t […]

  14. Lessons from the Humanitarian Sector: The Applicability of the Sphere Project’s Protection Principles | Human Trafficking Center

    […] – should be eligible for assistance. One important implication of this principle is that men and boys – frequently overlooked by service providers for victim-survivors of sex trafficking – should also receive […]

  15. Jerome Elam

    For seven long years I was trapped in a hell no one deserves. I was nothing more than a shell of a human being enduring suffering and torture at the hands of psychopaths and sociopaths as the world looked on. I attended school, and from the outside appeared to be a “normal child” but I was being trafficked in plain sight. I was often pulled out of school to “service” clients and after school, holidays and weekends were all just a never-ending nightmare for me. All of the signs were there but no one cared enough to look or had the training or education to realize my bruises and lengthy illnesses were all red flags for a child suffering endless abuse.

    The story of one. Trafficked Boys: Vandalized innocence hidden in plain sight
    Read more at http://www.commdiginews.com/life/trafficked-boys-vandalized-innocence-hidden-in-plain-sight-26356/#AbLL85mMbRRrMcxy.99

  16. September Human Trafficking News - Human Trafficking CenterHuman Trafficking Center

    […] Director of Advocacy Ashley Greve blogged about the need to recognize the prevalence of trafficking of men and boys, even within the commercial sex industry. Ashley discusses that at present, there are over 400,000 […]

  17. Christopher Anderson

    Ms. Greve,

    While I wholeheartedly applaud and endorse your effort to raise the point that male victims of trafficking must be acknowledged and supported, I am deeply concerned to see that you reference the outdated and absolutely incorrect statistic that only 2% of victims of sex trafficking are male in this post.

    According to research from ECPAT-USA, John Jay College, and others there is a great deal of evidence that far more than 2% of sex trafficking victims are male. According to the paper, “And Boys Too” that was recently issued by ECPAT-USA “as high as” 50% of survivors of sex trafficking may be male.

    Please help us correct this terrible error in the literature and public perceptions of the importance and scale of male victimization. Every survivor matters, and overlooking the millions of males around the world who are sex trafficked makes it far harder to address the overall picture of sex trafficking.

    Sincerely,
    Christopher M. Anderson
    Executive Director, MaleSurviovr

    • HTC

      Dear Mr. Anderson,

      Thank you for referring us to the study you cited by the John Jay College. The findings presented are definitely interesting and worth looking into. I encourage others to read this study and form their own opinions. I would like to point out, however, that this study is limited in both methodology and scope. The methodology employed is respondent-driven sampling, and while I am not about to propose a better sampling method, it does limit accessibility to non-street-based or hidden populations. In addition, while I agree that the findings are surprising and important, I would hesitate to extrapolate from this one study in one city alone that similar statistics would be found everywhere.

      I agree wholeheartedly with the need to pay more attention to men and boys and that male victimization is grossly under-reported due to expectations of gender norms, cultural beliefs and other considerations. As is clear from your thoughtful response, we share many ideas on this topic. The Human Trafficking Center will certainly try to accurately represent the research we find on this matter and not to fixate on females alone.

      Please stay in touch and continue challenging us with new research which may lead to a more balanced picture of the issue at hand.

      Sincerely,
      Ashley Greve
      Associate Director of Advocacy
      The Human Trafficking Center

Leave a comment